Napoleon’s Wars – Charles Esdaile

Many periods of human history interest and fascinate me, from classical antiquity through to the Cold War, but I always find myself coming back to the “Napoleonic” epoch.  The impact and backdrop of the Enlightenment and the French Revolution and the bewilderingly complex geopolitics and diplomacy of the time are part of the appeal, plus of course the presence of one towering and dominant figure – Napoleon Bonaparte.

A book which until recently had quietly been gathering dust on my shelves was “Napoleon’s Wars”, by Charles Esdaile.

NapoleonsWars

 

I have read a few books about the Napoleonic Wars, but this one stands out for several reasons.  The author does not fall for the misty-eyed romanticism and awe which seems to grip many of those who write about Napoleon, and he repeatedly highlights instances where compromise could have benefited France, and Europe and as a whole, but where the emperor’s ambition and ego won out, to the ultimate detriment of all concerned.  As the story progressed, I acquired a sense of how hollow some of Napoleon’s rhetoric had become.

Refreshingly, “Napoleon’s Wars” takes a very wide view of proceedings, with a great deal of attention devoted to the activities of Tsar Alexander I of Russia, who emerges as a complex and fascinating figure.  The broader strategic and diplomatic picture is deftly and astutely examined, with much emphasis placed on the Mediterranean, the Balkans and Poland.

A number of myths and “truths” have built up about certain aspects of the Napoleonic Wars.  Esdaile is at pains to dispel many of these, particularly those relating to supposed “uprisings” and resistance by civilians in several countries.  These assertions only serve to accentuate the intricate and contradictory nature of the conflict.

In this reading, Britain’s role in affairs hardly inspires, and the attitudes adopted by some of its statesmen are startling.  That they feared Napoleon and French power is understandable, but the word “reactionary” hardly suffices to describe the outlook of many in England.

Another factor which comes through in this rendering of the story is the often invidious, hopeless and desperate position of both Austria and Prussia, who, it is often forgotten, were impotent for large swathes of the era covered by this book.

Whilst it is true that the author is often critical of Napoleon’s lack of realism or moderation, he also highlights the frailties and shortcomings of rulers and statesmen on all sides, and the role which their intransigence/incompetence/myopia played in influencing the course of events.  The passages looking at some of the “minor” monarchies, and their courts, is particularly illuminating.

This book may not be the definitive account of the subject, and in fairness I don’t think it really set out to be that. However, it is a thought-provoking and in places compelling read.

Goethe’s Italian Journey

A little while ago, I purchased a compilation of some of the works of Johann Wolfgang von Goethe. I have been working my way through it,  and most recently reached the fascinating Italian Journey, which is based on diaries and letters written by the author during his travels in Italy in the years 1786-88. It seems that it was subsequently fine-tuned and added to, and was not published until many years after the event(s).

GoetheSelectedWorks

Much of Italian Journey is taken up with Goethe’s observations about nature, climate, architecture, art ,and social mores. His scientific theorizing also gets a substantial airing, as does his keen interest in mineral deposits and volcanoes!

In addition to being an entertaining document of a learned man’s travels, Italian Journey may also be seen as a snapshot of a time in history. The regions being explored by Goethe may not all have been undergoing quite the pace of change being seen elsewhere,  but he offers a window on how people lived and sustained themselves, and how, if at all, they were being affected by new ideas.

Goethe’s experiences are described in colourful and often humorous detail.  Although he strives to be tactful and constructive, he is occasionally quite blunt in his appraisal of places, people and cultural artefacts.  This never made me feel uncomfortable, however.

I felt that the writings became livelier and more robust when he reached Naples and then Sicily.  Less equivocal, and perhaps a sense of perspective is enabled by memories of his other stop-off points.  An accumulation of sights, sounds, exchanges, encounters and experiences makes his opinions seem more coherent and pungent.  As the journey unfolds, he is not afraid of flouting cosy consensus or dispelling myth.  The passages on culture, landscape and topography are broken up with some amusing tangential tales concerning local characters and traditions.

Goethe does not shrink from hinting at his ambivalence about some religious practices and political and social institutions. Such verdicts are expressed cryptically, but equally leave the reader in little doubt where his sympathies lie.  He seems to judge people on what resides in their hearts and minds, and not on their nominal rank or title.  This is refreshing.

As I became more engrossed in this work, I increasingly wondered what a 21st century equivalent would look and feel like.  Yes, people do travel widely today, and they do write perceptively and enticingly about their thoughts and experiences, but the particular tenor of those times, and Goethe’s unusually wide range of interests and concerns, give his writings here genuine character, depth and novelty.  Extra interest stems from the imagery of “forward thinkers” being hemmed in by, and coping with, the restrictions imposed by those times.  Creative people, reconciling the past and present with a changing world and fresh attitudes.

A modern day variant of Italian Journey would probably involve one of the polymaths of our times embarking on some kind of train journey through those regions.  It would still be a good read, but is the world now simply too homogenized, clinical, automated and above all, small, to afford much in the way of romance, spontaneity or unpredictability? Or is it the case that deep down people have not really changed that much, just their surroundings, and the specific means by which they strive to achieve the same goals, deal with the same fears, and fall prey to the same weaknesses?  Have “advances” and “progress” made people’s lives “better” but less “interesting”?  (quotes added advisedly).

Even then, was it the habit of “intellectuals” to look patronizingly on the “little people”, and romanticize about their lifestyles and customs?  To my mind,  this  phenomenon still exists today, if not necessarily in Europe. Asserting that they were a happy, simple people, is a convenient way of avoiding asking some awkward questions.  Those people might actually have welcomed a little Northern European “sophistication” in their lives. The charm and diversity which outside observers gushed effusively about may have been small comfort to some of those on the ground.

Quite aside from any such ruminations, Italian Journey is an entertaining, engaging and thought-provoking read, and is well worth seeking out.

Heatwave

Britain is currently “enjoying” a spell of hot and dry weather which could soon even begin to rival the notorious summers of the mid-1970s in terms of magnitude and length.   As somebody who is old enough to remember those long-lost heatwaves (and attendant droughts!), I have been reflecting on my changing attitudes to weather and the seasons.

Once upon a time, the summer was a period of discovery, wonder, adventure, exploration and joy.  Now, for me it is a time of inconvenience, irritation, discomfort, and unedifying spectacles.  I just want the whole thing to be over, and to give way to the more dignified and undemonstrative charms of autumn.

Since my teenaged years, and as my adult life has unfolded, the virtues of autumn have assumed a greater allure and importance. Cooler and less frenzied, and still with the ever-present chance of the sun emitting its healing qualities. The kids are safely back in school, and the landscape is blissfully tranquil and devoid of distractions.  We can feel almost alone and human again.

Autumn has its own beauty,  a kind of grace and vulnerability quite distinct from the tacky, shallow and egregious clamour of the preceding months. The slight melancholy which autumn both exudes and encourages tends to suit my solitary inclinations and my affinity for pathos.  The cooler temperatures and more subtle appeal to all of the senses which autumn entails permit more temperate reflection and reasoning.

Autumn also appeals to the individualist in me.  In its appearance and ambience it feels “unloved” and forsaken, left to its own devices. Summer for me simply promotes reversion to the unseemly.  Autumn is more akin to a blank canvas, where the mind is less cluttered and the possibilities are infinite.

Bring on late September!

Friendships

A recent conversation with a friend prompted me to reflect anew on the question of friendship, our social lives, and the compromises we sometimes have to make to facilitate these things, and to maintain an agreeable rhythm of life.

I will admit that I have for much of my adult life preferred my own company.  This solitary inclination in me is not due to any anti-social tendencies as such, but more of a sense that my interests, and “philosophy of life”, are somewhat out of kilter with those of my peers. In what may be a failure on my part, I increasingly abhor the kind of social interactions which require me to uphold some pretense of finding other people interesting or funny, or of sharing their interests and/or values.  Years of being forced to appear sincere in professional interactions may have triggered this stance in me. Small talk is not really my thing, unless I have some romantic motive!

The conversation with my friend also got me thinking about the extent to which developments in modern society have brought about these difficulties for many of us, and by the same token whether technological innovations may offer solutions.

It is fair to assume that an increasing proportion of modern day “friendships” are between work colleagues.  In my thirties, I went through a very gregarious phase, and socialized regularly and vigorously with various people with whom I worked.  Looking back though, I cannot honestly say that these were genuine friendships, but merely a conduit for me to let off some steam at the end of the working day or week.  The relationships were quite guarded, half-hearted and hollow.  There was usually precious little in the way of true mutual affection or philosophical common ground.

I know that previous and sincere friendships are often achieved between people who seemingly have very different interests and backgrounds, but I think that on these occasions those elements are happily complementary, rather than in conflict.  Any differences are defused or softened by a chemistry or serendipity which is quite rare.

So have modern communications offered a way out, and made it easier to cement worthwhile friendships and social bonds, by facilitating link-ups between people of similar interests and outlooks?    I am tempted to aver that even the much-vaunted connective power of the internet offers no guarantees.    Indeed, does  the internet merely promote the “fragmentation” of the human race, by driving people further into niche groups, which run the risk of becoming blinkered and defensive?

Is it simply the case that we have to make compromises in our social relationships, embracing even things which we find tedious and shallow, in order to maintain an agreeable balance and quality of life?  Do the earnest and the hollow combine to serve up a “one-ness”, which helps us to enjoy a harmonious and fulfilling life?  By seeking to insulate ourselves, are we just creating an unhealthy tension and narrowness in our own existence?  No matter what some of us might say, we all need other people…

I guess we  just have to swallow our pride, and lighten up a bit, but it’s easier said than done for some of us!

Hermann Hesse

Every so often, one encounters an author, composer or artist whose outlook, style and approach are perfectly in tune with one’s own concerns, hopes and sentiments at that precise period in time. This occurred with me around three years ago when for the first time I explored the novels of Hermann Hesse.

Although I had not read any of his works, I had been aware of Hesse for many years, and had a vague notion of the types of things which the novels addressed. I had even spotted one or two of his books in my local library during my teenaged years, but they seemed daunting to me. The mystique surrounding Hesse was intensified by his popularity with various musicians of the time, notably Brian May of Queen.

After those early glimpses the name of Hesse largely faded from my consciousness for the next two decades, and my cultural pursuits were overtaken by things more prosaic and shallow.  It was only after I passed the age of forty, and was afflicted by depression, that Hesse’s novels truly became an integral part of my life.

TheJourneyToTheEast

As I was receiving treatment, my own instincts, in addition to  the advice of the medical experts, told me that some long overdue intellectual and spiritual nourishment would greatly aid my recovery. My illness also led me tentatively in the direction of Eastern philosophy. These bases were covered by Hesse’s Siddhartha. To say that this novel (novella?) had a profound effect on me would be a gross understatement. At a low ebb, I was receptive to its themes of awakening and self-discovery, these being recurring features of the author’s output.

I vividly recollect being moved to tears by some of the passages in Siddhartha. It is a short work, and its messages are conveyed concisely and eloquently.  At the risk of sounding grandiose, I would even cite reading Siddhartha as a turning point for me, a life-changing episode of sorts, when I began to leave many old and stale attitudes behind.  This may have been the case for countless other people too.

Suitably inspired, I began to seek out many of Hesse’s other novels, although some of them are not that easy to get hold of here in England.  What oozes from the pages of Hesse is an endearing and infectious love of, and curiosity about, life, people and places, allied to an appreciation of the vitality and beauty to be found there.  Reading the books served to bring home to me just how jaded and detached we become, totally divorced from “home” and the essence of life. Small wonder that Hesse became very influential and fashionable in the 1960s and 1970s.

Demian

It is true that many of Hesse’s novels deal with similar topics, but they are so mesmeric, rich and engrossing that this never becomes a concern.  These themes include issues of rebirth, duality, journeys of self-discovery and spiritual awakening. At times Hesse also examines asceticism and scholarship, and tensions concerning the use or application of knowledge.  Steppenwolf offers a deviation in terms of setting and to some degree subject matter. The Glass Bead Game has sweep and an all-encompassing majesty that is quite breathtaking.  Those who are seeking something outwardly less ambitious but exuding an “organic” pastoral charm are well catered for by such works as Peter Camenzind, Narcissus and Goldmund and Rosshalde.

Rosshalde

Like much enduring art, the literature of Hermann Hesse radiates an intoxicating life-affirming quality. Whenever I finish reading one of his stories, I am seized with a desire to immerse myself in learning, nature and love. I can think of few more positive legacies than that. I would recommend his work to anyone wishing to reinvigorate themselves, or rediscover their zest for life, consciousness and knowledge.

A Trip Down Memory Lane…..Literally

It is funny how innocuous things can bring home the transient nature of life, and the relentless march of time.

A couple of days ago, I walked down the street where I used to live (its full length in both directions),  for the first time in many years.  The experience served to remind me how our roots and memories are so tenuous,  no matter how much we cling to  romantic notions of permanence and community.

It was a chilly, dank and rainy day, and this seemed an apposite backdrop for the emotions which initially traveled through me.  Outwardly, at first glance  the houses looked pretty much as they had done thirty years ago, but what struck me almost immediately was the general ambience.  The shiny window frames were more impervious to the elements, the cars parked in the resurfaced driveways more advanced, but the life,as I remembered it, had been drained from the street.  Or so it seemed…

As I made my way along, I came across places which held fond memories.  A set of porch steps where, one wistful summer’s evening circa 1978, I had sat with two younger companions, long after we would normally be summoned indoors by our parents, reveling in what seemed at the time an act of benign rebellion.  An area further on, now covered by modern houses, but which during my earlier childhood was waste ground, and which played host to our Guy Fawkes Night bonfires.  Several dwellings where I had spent countless carefree and innocent hours. Once children had played joyfully on these pavements, pausing occasionally to receive some sage advice from the more senior citizens.  None of that now.

When I first returned home, I felt a wave of nostalgia, tinged with regret at a time and place gone forever.  However, subsequent cooler reflection sparked more complex musings . I had allowed sentiment to reign, and equate the changes in my old neighbourhood with a perceived decline in our quality of life generally.   The friends who have moved elsewhere will doubtless have established new roots, instigating something in its own way every bit as vibrant and homely.  And who am I to judge what was wondrous and glorious all those years ago?  Many of the people around me at that time may have been, for all I knew, lonely, insecure or frustrated, longing for a fresh start.  Moreover, just because the modern-day residents do not conduct an endless Mardi Gras does not make them any less civil or human.

Life goes on.  Not better or worse, just differently. It just constantly evolves and reinvents itself.  I sometimes think that the the pangs which events of this kind evoke in us say less about 21st century life per se  than they do about ourselves as individuals.  Waxing lyrical about the past is much easier than confronting the present and the future….

Hamlet, Education and Life

One of the clearest memories which I retain from my high school days is from the time when my English Literature class was studying William Shakespeare’s Macbeth.   A few of us remarked how much we were relishing “the Scottish play”.  Our teacher, a most avuncular and kindly fellow, assured us that if we thought Macbeth was impressive, we should wait until we experienced Hamlet, which in his estimation was on a different level altogether.

That little interlude stayed with me in the ensuing decades. However, I never got around to reading Hamlet, much to my regret.  Until recently, that is.  As part of an effort to re-acquaint myself with Shakespeare, I read the play in its entirety.

Hamlet

My tentative verdict is that Hamlet is one of those works which demands repeated readings before its full philosophical and emotional depth can be appreciated. I find that one of the “perils” of reading Shakespeare is that one becomes so bound up and captivated by the rich and sinuous wordsmithery that some of the subtexts can slip through the cerebral net.  Hamlet, with its sweep and ambition, is a case in point.

Some of the character traits and themes which I was led to believe played a central role in the tale seemed barely discernible on this first visit.  Hence my suggestion that further readings should draw out the morals and nuances in the story.  It will be nice for the numerous strands of Hamlet to fall into place.  When they do, I will perform a knowing smile and a nod of approval, an acknowledgement of the portent of that exchange in a dusty classroom almost three decades ago.

This has all served to remind me of the  functions which aspects of our education fulfill at differing stages of our lives. In early adulthood, I was more concerned about the leverage to be gained by those little pieces of paper which the authorities called “certificates”, awarded to signify how well my powers of memory had coped in a hot and uncomfortable hall on a nerve-racking June morning.  Eventually, after a prolonged period of “sleepwalking”,  I became aware that for practical purposes, these adornments had actually counted for little, and less tangible “soft skills” were more desirable, the type with which schools don’t necessarily equip us.

As my life has unfolded, I have cultivated a healthy cynicism about much of the “advice” and counsel which I was given during my time in school. However, a few selected teachers did seem to have genuinely altruistic motives, going out of their way to share their enthusiasm for their subject, and not just blandly going through the professional motions.

Other than the aforementioned English tutor, there was a music teacher who exuded a genuine passion for his subject, which he was eager to transmit to us.  It was only twenty-odd years later that the seeds of my love for classical music, planted back then but hitherto dormant, germinated and flourished.  At an earlier stage, another teacher constantly sought to impress upon his pupils the importance of discarding our “blinkers” and appreciating the things around us, particularly nature and architecture.

It is perhaps significant, heartening even, that in among the morass of “knowledge” which was acquired and almost as quickly stagnated, those nuggets of encouragement still shone brightly.  When and if we step off the treadmill,  they are there to be picked up and harnessed, to genuinely enrich our lives.  I don’t remember calculus and algebra helping me to savour beauty, humanity and creativity…..

Welcome

Welcome to my blog.  It’s great to be here!

I will be blogging about life in its broadest sense, sometimes encompassing personal and philosophical themes, often drawing on history and culture.  I have no rigid plan of action, preferring to just set things in motion, and see where it leads….