Many periods of human history interest and fascinate me, from classical antiquity through to the Cold War, but I always find myself coming back to the “Napoleonic” epoch. The impact and backdrop of the Enlightenment and the French Revolution and the bewilderingly complex geopolitics and diplomacy of the time are part of the appeal, plus of course the presence of one towering and dominant figure – Napoleon Bonaparte.
A book which until recently had quietly been gathering dust on my shelves was “Napoleon’s Wars”, by Charles Esdaile.
I have read a few books about the Napoleonic Wars, but this one stands out for several reasons. The author does not fall for the misty-eyed romanticism and awe which seems to grip many of those who write about Napoleon, and he repeatedly highlights instances where compromise could have benefited France, and Europe and as a whole, but where the emperor’s ambition and ego won out, to the ultimate detriment of all concerned. As the story progressed, I acquired a sense of how hollow some of Napoleon’s rhetoric had become.
Refreshingly, “Napoleon’s Wars” takes a very wide view of proceedings, with a great deal of attention devoted to the activities of Tsar Alexander I of Russia, who emerges as a complex and fascinating figure. The broader strategic and diplomatic picture is deftly and astutely examined, with much emphasis placed on the Mediterranean, the Balkans and Poland.
A number of myths and “truths” have built up about certain aspects of the Napoleonic Wars. Esdaile is at pains to dispel many of these, particularly those relating to supposed “uprisings” and resistance by civilians in several countries. These assertions only serve to accentuate the intricate and contradictory nature of the conflict.
In this reading, Britain’s role in affairs hardly inspires, and the attitudes adopted by some of its statesmen are startling. That they feared Napoleon and French power is understandable, but the word “reactionary” hardly suffices to describe the outlook of many in England.
Another factor which comes through in this rendering of the story is the often invidious, hopeless and desperate position of both Austria and Prussia, who, it is often forgotten, were impotent for large swathes of the era covered by this book.
Whilst it is true that the author is often critical of Napoleon’s lack of realism or moderation, he also highlights the frailties and shortcomings of rulers and statesmen on all sides, and the role which their intransigence/incompetence/myopia played in influencing the course of events. The passages looking at some of the “minor” monarchies, and their courts, is particularly illuminating.
This book may not be the definitive account of the subject, and in fairness I don’t think it really set out to be that. However, it is a thought-provoking and in places compelling read.





